A comparison of proximity and land use regression traffic. Request pdf development of land use regression models for pm2. However, chinese urban areas differ from those in europe and north america, for example in respect of population. Land use regression lur was originally developed as a means to assess exposures from trafficrelated air pollution, and has since then become a widely used methodology in air pollution epidemiology. Spatiotemporal distributions and land use regression models of ambient bacteria and endotoxins in the greater taipei area kraiwuth kallawicha1, shihchun candice lung2, yingchih chuang1, chihda wu3, tsunhsuan chen4, yingjie tsai1, hsing jasmine chao1 1 school of public health, taipei medical university, taipei 110, taiwan. In the regression model, ecat was logtransformed, given a relatively lognormal distribution of ecat levels.
Modeling methods to estimate residential exposure to nitrogen. For instance, land use regression lur models are used to predict pollutant concentrations at unmonitored sites based on regression models of georeferenced covariates that predict observed i. Land use regression models for ultrafine particles, fine. These models use air pollution measurements taken at a small set of locations and modeling based on geographical covariates for which data are available at all study participant locations. Land use regression models of onroad particulate air. Lur modelling is based on characteristics related to the overall trends of air pollutants concentrations mainly for longer time scales.
Levels of pollution may then be predicted for any location, such as individual homes, using the parameter estimates derived from the regression model. Spatiotemporal land use regression models of fine, ultra ne. Systematic evaluation of land use regression models for. Predictive ability of logistic regression, autologistic. Assessing spatial variability of ambient nitrogen dioxide. Land use regression models as a tool for short, medium and long term exposure to traffic related air pollution. Development and evaluation of landuse regression models. The present research deals with a new development of nonlinear lur models based on machine learning algorithms. Pdf development of no2 and nox land use regression models. Land use lu regression exposure models are commonly used in health studies, yet since the lu terms are generally not time varying, their temporal resolution tends to be limited, and based on the spatial resolution of the available pm 2. Ambient bacteria ranged from use of exposure indicator variables, interpolation methods, dispersion models and land use regression lur models.
So far these changes have been observed mainly on a temporal scale while spatial changes have rarely been considered. Compared to dispersion models, the land use regression method requires less detailed input data at the expense of the need to obtain monitoring data for a sufficiently large number 4080 of sites. A new technique for evaluating landuse regression models an. In practice, land use models are demanddriven, using as inputs the aggregate information on growth produced by an aggregate economic forecasting activity.
Land use regression lur is an empirical approach to describing the spatial or spatiotemporal variability in air pollution concentrations. This requires some linkage to the environmental characteristics of the area, especially characteristics that influence pollutant emission intensity and dispersion efficiency. Spatial variations and development of land use regression models a. The data will also be used as the geographic base for all gis data sets.
Is a land use regression model capable of predicting the. One approach can be found in 16 agentbased models abms, which aim to capture the intrinsic nature of land use patterns by 17 simulating agentenvironment interactions see, e. Avariety of methods such as kappa and multiresolution validation were used to compare the simulation results for 1993 and 1998 with independent. The goal of this study is to develop an lur estimate for no 2 in hamilton, ontario, canada. Land use forecasting undertakes to project the distribution and intensity of trip generating activities in the urban area.
Original research land use regression models using. We aimed to compare the contribution of sat and ctm data to the performance of lur pm 2. Spatiotemporal distributions and landuse regression models. The objective of this study was to develop a land use. The use of stationary measurements at a limited number of locations to build a lur model, however, can lead to an overestimation of its predictive abilities. This study developed seasonal landuse regression lur models to.
Land use regression lur models may be an appropriate alternative to assess intraurban air pollution caused by the large number of pollutant sources and the rapid decay of many urban pollutants briggs et al. Measurement error in epidemiologic studies of air pollution. Urban land use change model for the study area are developed using ols and gwr tools. Pdf development and evaluation of land use regression models. Development, evaluation, and comparison of land use regression. Selfadaptive revised land use regression models for. Mar 20, 2007 we use multinomial logistic regression models solely for projecting change, finding that accuracies of maps produced vary by land cover classification and are influenced by differing spatial resolutions of socioeconomic and biophysical data. We developed lur models for nitrogen dioxide no2 using measurements conducted at 144 sampling sites in the netherlands.
With the rise of mobile air pollution campaigns, characterized by shortterm monitoring and large spatial extents, it is important to investigate the effects of sampling protocols on the resulting lur. The land use regression model described above can be used to predict roadlevel bc concentrations and thus predict the concentrations a cyclist is exposed to while cycling. Can we improve air pollution estimates when extending land. Landuse types and major determinants of the bioaerosols were used to develop regression models. Pdf abstract land use regression lur modelling is increasingly used in epidemiological studies to predict air pollution exposure. Currently the package includes two inductive land use change models. Can we improve air pollution estimates when extending land use regression models to adjacent cities or backward in time. However, typical lur models have a limited sampling point explanation rate sper, i. Applying land use regression model to estimate spatial. Land use regression as method to model air pollution. Pdf land use regression lur modeling is a widely used technique to model the spatial variability of air pollutants in epidemiology. Ambient bacteria ranged from land use were estimated by geographic information system in buffers ranging 50 to 500 mradii.
Wang m, beelen r, eeftens m, meliefste k, hoek g, brunekreef b. However, people spend more time indoors, where these methods are less explored. Landuse regression utilizes the monitored levels of the pollutant of interest as the dependent variable and variables such as traffic, topography, and other geographic variables as the independent variables in a multivariate regression model gilliland et al. Current approaches for assessing intraurban air pollution contrasts include the use of exposure indicator variables, interpolation methods, dispersion models and land use regression lur models.
P ii 18 development of landuse regression models for air. Sep 30, 2010 abstract source contributions to urban fine particulate matter pm 2. Regression techniques for examining land usecover change. Pdf intercity transferability of land use regression. The urban land area of the study site has increased from.
The ministry of education key laboratory for earth system modeling. Nitrogen dioxide levels estimated from land use regression. Pdf is a land use regression model capable of predicting. Land use regression integrated environmental health impact. Atmosphere free fulltext landuse regression modelling. Performance of multicity land use regression models for.
May 30, 2014 for instance, land use regression lur models are used to predict pollutant concentrations at unmonitored sites based on regression models of georeferenced covariates that predict observed i. Land use regression lur models are promising for estimating the spatial distribution of pm2. Original research land use regression models using satellite. Land use regression lur models are now being applied to simulate pollutant concentrations with high spatial resolution in chinese urban areas. For each training set, we developed models and evaluated them using a crossholdout validation approach. We aimed to compare measured and estimated no2 levels 12 years apart, the stability of the exposure estimates for members of a large cohort study, and. P ii 18 development of landuse regression models for. Land use regression lur models are increasingly used to estimate air pollution exposure in epidemiologic studies. Development of no2 and nox land use regression models for estimating air pollution exposure in 36 study areas in europe the escape project. Sites were randomly divided into training data sets with a size of 24, 36, 48, 72, 96, 108, and 120 sites.
Abstract land use regression lur models have emerged as a preferred methodology for estimating individual exposure to ambient air pollution in epidemiologic studies in absence of subjectspecific measurements. Landuse regression methods can benefit from a more systematic selection and description of monitoring locations and monitoring periods. Moreover, no models have been previously presented for the lung deposited surface area ldsa of ultrafine. Lur models have been increasingly used in the past few years. The saviah study was the first to use land use regression to model small scale variations in air pollution briggs et al. A land use regression model lur model is an algorithm often used for analyzing pollution, particularly in densely populated areas the model is based on predictable pollution patterns to estimate concentrations in a particular area. Incorporating local land use regression and satellite. Land use regression lur models typically use fixedsite monitoring.
A land use regression model for predicting ambient. Background lur models have been applied in 9 countries and 14. Backgroundaim epidemiological studies show that changes in air temperature affect mortality and morbidity. Rapid urbanization in china is leading to substantial adverse air quality issues, particularly for no2 and particulate matter pm. There are currently no epidemiological studies on health effects of longterm exposure to ultrafine particles ufp, largely because data on spatial exposure contrasts for ufp is lacking. Abstract source contributions to urban fine particulate matter pm 2. Evaluation of land use regression models for no 2 and particulate matter in 20 european study areas. Spatiotemporal distributions and landuse regression models of. Conclusion application of land use regression model for tehran city shows the high accuracy of the model for predictions of three pollutants in four seasons. A spatiotemporal landuse regression model of winter fine. One approach gaining considerable interest is the landuse regression lur model. Assessing the suitability of multiple dispersion and land.
Generally, the lur model has been utilized to characterize air pollution exposure and health effects for. Land use and traffic characteristics were derived for each sampling location and participating infants birth residence using arcgis 9. Few studies have evaluated the stability of spatial contrasts in outdoor nitrogen dioxide no2 concentration over several years. Spatial variations and development of land use regression. The lur model combines the monitoring of air pollution within a certain spatial scale and the development of stochastic models using gis.
Pdf land use regression model for ultrafine particles in. Air pollution mapping using nonlinear land use regression. Spatiotemporal distributions and landuse regression. The aim of the study was to generate individuallevel indicators of longterm average exposure to ambient air pollution to assess the risks of respiratory disease of children. Exploring the modeling of spatiotemporal variations in. The development of a landuse regression model for ultrafine. Less common forms of regression use slightly different procedures to estimate alternative location parameters e. Kelly sabaliaukas, cheolheon jeong, xiaohong yao, christopher reali, and tim 5 sun, greg evans 6 7 corresponding author. Source apportionment of indoor residential fine particulate. We used land use regression lur models to predict the spatial variability of temperature and relative humidity and to detect urban heat islands in the augsburg region.
Recently, the application of land use regression models lur for air pollution analysis and mapping in urban zones has demonstrated their efficiency. Land use regression lur modeling is a widely used technique to model the spatial variability of air pollutants in epidemiology. Pdf applying land use regression model to estimate spatial. Development and evaluation of land use regression models. Studies differ in the monitoring data that are used to develop land use regression models. Land use regression models lur for reliable estimation of. Exploring the modeling of spatiotemporal variations in ambient air. Jul 18, 2012 land use regression models lur are useful to estimate the spatial variability of air pollution in urban areas. Landuse regression lur models are useful for resolving fine scale spatial variations in average air pollutant concentrations across urban areas. Land use regression lur modelling is increasingly used in epidemiological studies to predict air pollution exposure. An emerging alternative is the estimation of pollutant concentrations using land use characteristics, such as traffic volumes, industrial sources, and population density. These models are then used as a tool for exposure assessment in epidemiological studies. Pdf land use regression models as a tool for short, medium.
Systematic evaluation of land use regression models for no 2. Our goal was to evaluate the ability of dispersion caline4, aermod, rline, and quic and regression models to predict pnc in a residential neighborhood somerville and an urban center chinatown near highways in and near boston, massachusetts. Development of landuse regression models for metals associated. In this study, we explore whether a lur model can predict hometoschool commuting exposure to black carbon bc. Land use regression lur models have become popular to explain the spatial variation of air pollution concentrations. Lur is based on the principle that pollutant concentrations at any location depend on the environmental characteristics of the surrounding area particularly those that influence or reflect emission intensity and dispersion efficiency. Land use regression lur is a popular method to explain and predict spatial contrasts in air pollution concentrations, but lur models for ultrafine particles, such as particle number concentration pnc are especially scarce. Ward a constantinos sioutas c roel vermeulen b d debra t. A spatiotemporal land use regression model of winter fine particulate levels in residential neighbourhoods skip to main content thank you for visiting. These data are key inputs to the land use regression models. Because the land use characteristics of different complete circular surfaces centered on a point e. Kerolyn shairsingh 1, cheolheon jeong1, jonathan wang2, jeff brook, greg evans1 1. Development and evaluation of land use regression models for. Spatiotemporal modeling of ozone levels in quebec canada.
Robustness of landuse regression models developed from. The amount of land use change between 1990 and 2005 is obtained by subtracting urban land area of 2005 to that of 1990. In this paper, modeling of the temporal and spatial variation in ambient pm 10 particulate matter with an aerodynamic diameter land use regression conceptual. The model is based on predictable pollution patterns to estimate concentrations in a particular area.
We aimed to estimate spatiotemporal variations of pm2. Intercity transferability of land use regression models for estimating ambient concentrations of nitrogen dioxide. Systematic evaluation of land use regression models for no2. Though land use regression models lurs are often used for this purpose, their applicability to later periods of time, larger geographic areas, and seasonal variation is largely untested. Modelling urban land use change using geographically. A land use regression model lur model is an algorithm often used for analyzing pollution, particularly in densely populated areas. Based on the land use change probabilities calculated by the above models, the land use change model clues simulated backward land use patterns in 1993 and 1998 for the validation. Land use regression lur has been widely used in predicting spatiotemporal variation of ambient airpollutant concentrations, though restricted to the european and north american context. Land use regression models lur for reliable estimation. Request pdf systematic evaluation of land use regression models for no2 land use regression lur models have become popular to explain the spatial variation of air pollution concentrations.
Development and validation of land use regression and other exposure models 5. Kockelman corresponding author 14 professor and william j. In this chapter, we introduce the concept of a regression model, discuss several varieties of them, and introduce the estimation method that is most commonly used with regression models. Development of a land use regression model for black. Spatiotemporal land use regression models of fine, ultra. The lur model, in contrast, assumes independence between sampled locations. Land use regression lur modeling is an extensively used exposure estimate. Title page abstract introduction conclusions references tables figures j i j i back close full screen esc printerfriendly version interactive discussion abstract relatively little is known about long term e. We randomly generated 10 training and test sets for nitrogen dioxide and particulate matter. In order to visualize the geographical distribution of pollution concentration realistically, we applied the land. Generally, the lur model has been utilized to characterize air pollution. Application of land use regression model to predict. Land use regression models were used to estimate residential exposure to air pollutants.
Land use regression models for ultrafine particles, fine particles, and black carbon in southern california author links open overlay panel rena r. National pm and no exposure models for china based on. Land use regression lur modeling is an important approach that has been applied successfully in many studies to predict longterm average pollutant concentrations at the intraurban scale. Estimation of pm10 concentrations on a daily basis. Assessing spatial variability of ambient nitrogen dioxide in. This approach adopts more stable variables characteristics of land use.
Important aspects are the use of routine versus purposedesigned networks, monitored pollutant, the number and distribution of monitoring sites and temporal resolution. Jul 02, 2015 land use regression lur models typically use fixedsite monitoring. Land use regression lur models are used to explain the measured spatial variation of the concentration of a pollutant by geographic predictor variables such as elevation, traffic density, road networks and industrial land use. The resulting data are used to build and crossvalidate a land use regression model for predicting black carbon concentrations that covers the entire city.
1410 333 741 406 1297 552 1444 402 160 1008 1312 1488 160 253 239 921 599 679 821 820 253 1303 1657 556 12 1125 297 799 460 1243 1181 734 494 1141 1405 312 1283 88 234 1481 332 1358 1189 393 963 22 358